Africa as a continent continues to face a dwindling economy, even amidst numerous resources, whether natural, social, intellectual, or environmental. Although regional economies like ECOWAS had potential to emulate the EU in forming a strong economic bloc in West Africa, they struggled, particularly with the implementation of a single currency. Rather than focusing on this, let’s quickly look at the success story of the European Union’s economy and explore why ECOWAS faced challenges, along with its prospects and possible solutions.
The success story of European Union EU
The European Union (EU) stands out as a remarkable example of regional cooperation. The idea of unity in Europe is not new, with early examples under the Roman Empire, Charlemagne, and Napoleon Bonaparte I. These earlier attempts at unity were based on force and conquest, unlike the post-World War II efforts focused on cooperation, security, and economic recovery. Below are some key steps that led to the creation of the modern EU.
Key Milestones in EU Formation
1948: European leaders gathered in The Hague, vowing to prevent future wars.
1950: France and Germany began cooperation in coal and steel, forming the European Coal and Steel Community (ECSC) by 1952.
1957: ECSC members established the European Economic Community (EEC) and Euratom.
1967: EEC, ECSC, and Euratom merged to form the European Community (EC).
1973–1990: Several countries, including Denmark, Ireland, the UK, Greece, Portugal, and Spain, joined the EC. Germany’s reunification also expanded the membership.
1993: Creation of the European Union (EU) based on further economic and political integration.
The Goals and Objectives of the EU
The EU was established to achieve specific objectives:
Eliminate Trade Barriers: Removing cross-border trade restrictions.
Promote Technical Cooperation: Encouraging collaboration that could evolve into political unity.
Establish a Tariff for Non-Members: Maintaining a tariff wall for non-EU countries.
Harmonize Monetary Union: Introducing a single currency to promote stability.
Develop Common Policies: Establishing unified foreign and security policies.
Major Administrative Structures of the EU
The EU operates with a robust administrative framework:
1. European Council: Sets general policy guidelines.
2. European Parliament: Holds legislative power and manages budget control.
3. Council of the EU: Composed of representatives from each member state.
4. European Commission: Ensures compliance with EU treaties.
5. Court of Auditors: Monitors financial management.
6. Court of Justice: Enforces compliance with EU rules.
7. Economic and Social Committee: Proposes technical initiatives.
The Euro and Monetary Unification
Background and Implementation of the Euro
In 1992, European leaders signed a treaty that laid the foundation for a unified market, a central bank, and a single currency, aiming to remove exchange rate restrictions. The Economic Monetary Union (EMU) introduced the euro, which officially launched in 1999. The European Central Bank (ECB), founded in 1998, plays a crucial role in managing the euro and stabilizing monetary policy.
Benefits of the Euro
Reduced Exchange Rate Risks: The euro minimizes currency exchange issues.
Competitive European Firms: A unified currency enhances the competitive power of European businesses.
Greater Investment Appeal: With a market of 370 million people, the EU attracts more investments from the U.S., Japan, and other global investors.
The Impact of Economic Integration in Europe
Advantages of EU Membership
Today, EU citizens enjoy the freedom to move, work, and set up businesses across member states. This has fostered economic growth, especially in poorer regions of the EU. Trade barriers have been removed, leading to a large and stable economic area that appeals to both European and foreign investors.
Economic Challenges
Despite successes, the EU faces challenges:
Economic Slowdown: Some EU countries report slower growth and inflation.
Weaker Euro: Economic concerns have occasionally led to a decline in the euro’s value.
National Tensions: Issues like high unemployment and regional disputes add pressure to the EU’s stability.
Comparison with Africa’s ECOWAS and Integration Efforts
Differences in Regional Integration
While the EU has made significant strides, African integration efforts, especially through the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS), have faced setbacks. Political instability, lack of mutual trust, and economic challenges have hindered progress.
Integration and Development in Africa: The Setbacks of ECOWAS
While economic integration in Europe has largely been a success story, Africa faces numerous obstacles in replicating this model, particularly through its regional body, the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS). Africa’s founding leaders saw integration as essential for development, yet the vision has struggled to move from intention to action. The setbacks are substantial, often rooted in security concerns, political challenges, and trust issues among African states.
Historical Push for Integration
Africa has long pursued integration. In 1958, African leaders recognized economic cooperation as critical, and in 1963, the Organization of African Unity (OAU) formalized this goal. Various summits over the following years sought to establish a roadmap toward an African Economic Community (AEC), aiming to achieve stages of preferential trade, free trade, a customs union, and eventually a common market. Although these plans were ambitious, implementation has stalled. Initially set for 2000, the AEC’s full establishment has been postponed to 2035.
Sub-Regional Integration Efforts
Numerous regional bodies were intended to support continental integration, including ECOWAS in West Africa, the Southern African Development Community (SADC), and the Common Market for Eastern and Southern Africa (COMESA). Despite support from organizations like the United Nations and the European Union, results have been underwhelming. Many African leaders struggle to mobilize their nations and develop the productive sectors necessary for integration.
Challenges Faced by ECOWAS
A closer look at ECOWAS reveals some of the core issues impeding African integration:
1. Lack of Trust and Mutual Confidence:
Divisions persist between Anglophone and Francophone members, undermining group unity. Nigeria, a key player in forming ECOWAS, is often viewed with suspicion. This lack of cohesion and trust affects decision-making, as overlapping membership in other regional organizations further complicates relations.
2. Fiscal Policy and Trade Restrictions
ECOWAS lacks a single currency, and the lack of cross-border trade is evident; in 1988, inter-community trade within ECOWAS was only 4.9%. Most member states rely heavily on exports to non-African markets, and ECOWAS has not developed the economic foundation needed for sustained intra-regional trade.
Based on the available data, here’s an approximate calculation of the overall percentage of intra-ECOWAS trade:
- Intra-ECOWAS Trade (2019-2020)
- Total ECOWAS trade: $208.1 billion
- Intra-ECOWAS exports: $34.6 billion (16.6% of total trade)
- Intra-ECOWAS imports: $24.5 billion (11.8% of total trade)
- Percentage of Intra-ECOWAS Trade
- Share of intra-ECOWAS trade in total ECOWAS trade: 14.2% ($59.1 billion / $208.1 billion)
- Average intra-regional trade intensity index: 12.3% (UN definition: ratio of intra-regional trade to total trade)
- Breakdown by country
- Nigeria: 2.4% of its total trade is intra-ECOWAS
- Ghana: 21.1% of its total trade is intra-ECOWAS
- Côte d’Ivoire: 25.5% of its total trade is intra-ECOWAS
- Regional Comparison
- EU: 67% of total trade is intra-EU
- ASEAN: 23% of total trade is intra-ASEAN
- SADC (Southern African Development Community): 22% of total trade is intra-SADC
- ECOWAS aims to increase intra-regional trade to 25% of total trade by 2025.
Sources:
1. ECOWAS Commission (2020) – ECOWAS Trade Report
2. African Development Bank (2020) – African Trade Report
3. UN Conference on Trade and Development (2020) – Trade and Development Report.
3. Weak Political Economy
The economies of ECOWAS states are often dependent on neocolonial trade structures, with weak private sectors and a dependence on foreign aid and capital. This reliance stifles the region’s capacity for self-sustaining economic growth. Debt is a persistent problem, with some West African states spending up to 30% of export earnings on debt servicing.
4. Political Instability and Security Challenges
Successful integration requires political stability, as seen in the European Union’s model. ECOWAS countries face frequent internal and cross-border conflicts, which destabilize the region. The organization also lacks a robust mechanism for security coordination, an essential factor for fostering trust and cooperation.
5. Limited Public Awareness and Support Many West Africans see ECOWAS as a project primarily led by political and economic elites, which creates a disconnect between the organization and ordinary citizens. This perception makes people feel that ECOWAS doesn’t address their everyday needs or challenges, limiting their interest and involvement. We will elaborate more on this in our subsequent bulletins.
6. Globalization and the New World Order
Globalization and the New World Order refers to the influence of global interconnectedness and international competition on regional organizations like ECOWAS. Globalization requires countries and regions to be competitive in trade, investment, and economic policies to integrate smoothly into the global market. However, ECOWAS struggles to keep up with these demands due to its internal issues.
ECOWAS struggles to adapt to the demands of globalization. Political instability and economic inefficiencies hamper its ability to attract foreign investment and engage in global trade. The lack of economies of scale further weakens its position in a competitive global market.
Prospects for ECOWAS and Regional Integration
Despite these setbacks, there remains potential for progress if ECOWAS member states address these core challenges. Essential steps include fostering trust, restructuring economies to support integration, and creating unified security policies. While the road ahead is difficult, a cooperative approach and commitment to mutual interests can provide a foundation for regional growth and development.
Please share this article
